At Work

Evangelism Is Not Enough to Change the World

Email Print

Although it has been written out of most secular accounts, historical evidence demonstrates that Christians have had a culture-shaping influence on Western Civilization. Sociologist Rodney Stark writes,

The success of the West, including the rise of science, rested entirely on religious foundations, and the people who brought it about were devout Christians.

Despite this historical influence, James Davison Hunter notes in To Change the World that Christians have employed several failed tactics in an effort to influence cultural change. Hunter specifically mentions evangelism as one of these failed tactics. For many people, evangelism is not only about saving souls. It’s a strategy for changing hearts and minds. When hearts and minds change, culture changes.

Except that, over the last 100 years, evangelism has failed to be an effective strategy for shaping culture. The reason why is found in Genesis 1.

God gives Adam and Eve their job description in Genesis 1:28. He tells them they were created to fill the earth with his images and subdue it, making it useful for the benefit and enjoyment of humans. The gospel of Jesus Christ redeems us, empowers us, and calls us back to this original calling.

It is important to understand both parts of this calling and see the difference between them. The church has been faithful to the first part of this calling to fill the earth with God’s (redeemed) images. This is evangelism and discipleship. These are vital activities.

But the church has forgotten to subdue the earth. Carrying out this second responsibility changes culture. Shaping, changing, and directing culture results from the work of our hands. It is not what we believe but what we do that transforms our institutions, communities, and families.

As I write in IFWE’s new booklet, All Things New, we have reduced the gospel. We have made it all about us. To quote Dallas Willard, “We have turned the gospel into the gospel of sin-management.” God did not save us, as Richard Pratt writes, “to forgive our sin, make our souls sparkle, to sprinkle us with peace and joy so we can sprout wings when we die, grab a harp, and join the eternal choir.”

God brought each of us out of darkness and into the light so we might be the light of the world (Matt. 5:14-16). He intended for us to impact the world with the truth of the whole gospel. This is why having a correct view of work is so important.

In an essay titled “Catechesis, Preaching, and Vocation,” Gene Veith writes*,

The task of restoring truth to the culture depends largely on our laypeople.

He then says:

To bring back truth, on a practical level, the church must encourage Christians to be not merely consumers of culture but makers of culture. The church needs to cultivate Christian artists, musicians, novelists, filmmakers, journalists, attorneys, teachers, scientists, business executives, and the like, teaching its laypeople the sense in which every secular vocation…is a sphere of Christian ministry, a way of serving God and neighbor that is grounded in God’s truth. Christian laypeople must be encouraged to be leaders in their fields, rather than eager-to-please followers, working from the assumptions of their biblical worldview, not the vapid cliches of pop culture.

The work of Christians down through the ages has built the great architectural structures of the West, constructed hospitals, founded schools and universities, abolished slavery, created great inventions, and written and painted and composed the incredible works of art civilization has enjoyed for centuries. These Christians saw all this work as part of subduing the earth.

Evangelism and discipleship are vitally important. Nothing we build matters without a personal relationship with the One who built the universe. But once we know him, everything we do is filled with a special purpose, a calling to use our work to glorify him, serve the common good, and further his kingdom. In other words, to radically impact our surrounding culture through the work of our hands.

God put us here to change the world. We have a lot of work to do.

*The original version of this post was published with these quotes mistakenly attributed to J. Gresham Machen. We regret the error. Veith’s essay can be found in Here We Stand: A Call from Confessing Evangelicals for a Modern Reformation, a collection of essays edited by James Montgomery Boice and Benjamin E. Sasse. Our version of the collection is P&R Publishing Company’s 2004 reissue. Veith’s quotes can be found on page 95. 

Have our latest content delivered right to your inbox!
  • Amen! That is a core message of Discipleship.Network

  • Steve Lindsey

    Great post Hugh. Where did that Machen quote come from?

  • While I agree that evangelism by itself isn’t enough, if we don’t succeed at it nothing else is possible.

    “The work of Christians down through the ages has built the great architectural structures of the West…”

    Yes, but in a society that was at least nominally Christian. The West since the late 1800s has become increasingly pagan. The number of believers has shrunk dramatically. We are a tiny minority. In addition, the nominal Christians have abandoned us and are becoming much more pagan. We are much more like Christians living in Muslims cultures. We are increasingly marginalized and have little influence on them.

    A declining culture is the natural consequence of every society that rebels against God and there is nothing we can do about it unless a larger percent of people become believers.

    And I don’t think the failure of evangelism is the fault of Christians. As Paul wrote in Romans 1, they know the truth but suppress it.

    • Russ McCullough

      You make some good points. However, I think that greater awareness of the importance of work will help bring in more fringe Christians who are passionate and successful in their work but do not connect their secular work with the glory of God. This insight leads to a redeemed purpose and can be a pathway for changing culture.

      • I agree, and clearly we need more Christians in all professions. I just disagree that evangelism and cultural change can be separated. Pagans may appreciate Christian architecture and science, but it will never appreciate Christian art, music and literature.

  • Scott Breslin

    Hi Hugh,
    I think your main point is valid and edifying but when you say:

    “The work of Christians down through the ages has built the great architectural structures of the West…”

    I think It weakens your arguement. If we want to claim the achievements of the so called “West” for Christians then by default the failings of the West are also the responsibility of Christians (hmmm.. maybe this is truer then I think. I like to blame non-Christians for all the bad stuff). This statement is not needed to support your thesis and it is too much of an over statement. It implies that there was a golden age or ‘good old days’ when vibrant Christianity thrived in Europe or the Americas. In my reading of history, that is just not the case. This does not lessen the huge impact of Christians… but, as you say, our evangelical church cultures do very little to reward, reinforce or expect beleivers to impact society except in evangelism. We need to see this change. I greatly appriciate your wisdom and leadership in this. Keep up the good work!

  • Thanks for sharing your perspective Hugh. I have been inspired by the work and perspective that you all do. May God continue to bless.

Further readings on At Work

  • At Work
Five Questions to Ask Yourself Before Changing Jobs

By: Dr. Andrew Spencer

4 minute read

Sometimes job changes occur out of necessity; one job ends and we need to find a new one to pay the bills….

  • At Work
  • Public Square
Are We Really Out of Big Ideas?

By: Hugh Whelchel

6 minute read

We’re all aware that we’re hip deep in the “Tech Age.” In a recent Wall Street Journal op-ed, Greg Ip…

Have our latest content delivered right to your inbox!