As we discussed last week, the U.S. dropped from the second most economically free country in the world in 2000 to the eighteenth in 2012 and is currently tied with Canada for eleventh place, according to the latest rankings.
One of the major reasons we’ve lost economic freedom is because humans, by nature, hate uncertainty. We try to plan and control the future to reduce uncertainty.
Usually, when we try to control future economic outcomes, it makes things worse. Our natural human fear of uncertainty is what drives our government to pass more regulatory legislation, suffocating economic freedom. When we lose economic freedom, we lose human flourishing. We are worse off than we were before, and the poor suffer the most.
This fear of uncertainty is part of our human nature. It is a spiritual problem that affects our personal lives as well as our nation at the policy level.
There is another aspect of human nature that causes us to lose economic freedom: freedom itself is scary.
We’re Terrified of Freedom
You might think of freedom as something that makes life easier. It means fewer rules and more room to do what you want to do with your life. This is true in a sense, but at the same time, freedom is a burden.
Freedom doesn’t require less of us. It requires more. To many, the burden of freedom is a scary thing.
Michael Novak says in Counting the Cost: Christian Perspectives on Capitalism:
It cannot be supposed that human beings always love liberty. Free persons must meet the burdens of personal responsibility, and for some, that responsibility is too onerous. If I may paraphrase Dostoevsky: “When people cry out for liberty, give it to them—in fifteen minutes they will give it back.” For most of history, humans have been remarkably unrebellious under tyranny. Meet their simplest appetites, and why should they take up irksome responsibilities?
So it is today. Not all human beings desire to be economically free; for if they are free, they are obligated to bear responsibility for their own welfare. Of course, there is always some percentage of the population who are too old or too young, too ill or too disabled, to carry their own weight in economic responsibility. There will always be some people who rightly depend upon the help of others. By its own moral identity, any honest Jewish, Christian, or even secular humanist society must come to their aid.
Freedom means we have a huge responsibility to care for our neighbors and trust they will come to our assistance when we are in need.
We are scared of freedom because the burden is heavy. We do not trust ourselves or others to carry the burden, so we continue to hand over our freedom to someone or something we think can manage it better, like government, even when giving up economic freedom to government leads to lower levels of human flourishing.
Freedom is a burden, but we are always better off with it than without it.
Freedom Is What We’re Made for
These two natural human tendencies that cause us to lose economic freedom, our disdain for uncertainty and our fear of freedom, are both spiritual problems.
It makes sense why we lose economic freedom when we look at our sinful human nature, but we need to remember how God created us. We were created to flourish and we were created to be free, and freedom leads to flourishing.
Economic freedom is the force wiping out poverty across the globe. It is the reason so many people around the world are not starving to death today.
It gives us the best chance to provide more opportunities for people of all income levels, not just for the wealthy.
If we really want to fight poverty, we have to fight for economic freedom for everyone, at home and abroad, in spite of our fears.
Editor’s Note: Read more about the biblical view of freedom in Free Indeed: Living Life in Light of the Biblical View of Freedom, a booklet available in the IFWE bookstore.
Help more people understand the important connection between faith, work, and economics! Support IFWE today.
On “Flashback Friday,” we take a look at some of IFWE’s former posts that are worth revisiting. This post was previously published on May 21, 2015 and has been updated.